
by Akhil. a young Keralan worker
The bourgeoisie can use any political form to protect its interests. After the Second World War, the European bourgeoisie used social democracy to stabilise capitalism and reduce the threat of communist revolution. By granting reforms and making concessions to workers, the ruling class helped preserve the capitalist system.The bourgeoisie does not depend on one political form. It can use social democracy, liberal democracy, Bonapartism or fascism, depending on the situation. The government may change, but capitalist power can remain intact. The task of progressive forces is to break this cycle and establish a society based on working-class power.
The BJP and the Limits of Its Power
In India, the BJP faces opposition from Congress, CJP, Youth, regional parties and other political forces. Rahul Gandhi’s growing political importance and the weakening of some regional parties have increased Congress’s role as a parliamentary alternative to the BJP.
The BJP is a right-wing populist force with authoritarian and fascistic tendencies. At the same time, it shows political flexibility. It can adjust its approach to different regions and social groups, taking positions in Nagaland that may differ from those it takes in Uttar Pradesh. This flexibility helps the BJP maintain its influence across a diverse country. However, this flexibility is also a weakness. The BJP cannot impose the same political approach everywhere without facing resistance and political limits. It must adjust to local conditions, regional interests and different social groups. This shows that its power is not unlimited and that it cannot simply reshape Indian society according to its wishes.
Capitalism is facing serious crises, but a crisis alone does not automatically lead to fascism. Fascism develops under specific conditions, particularly when the ruling class faces a serious threat to its power. At present, India lacks a sufficiently strong and organised working-class movement capable of challenging capitalist rule as a whole. This weakens the immediate pressure on the ruling class to use full-scale fascism to crush a revolutionary workers’ movement. However, authoritarianism and repression can grow even without such a threat.
If the BJP becomes a problem for sections of big business, they may turn towards Congress or another parliamentary alternative. A Congress government could restore some democratic space and provide relief from certain forms of repression. But it would not automatically change the capitalist character of the state.
The bourgeoisie can change its political form whenever necessary to protect its interests. If the working class remains dependent on parliamentary parties, the cycle will continue.
Congress, CJP and Popular Leaders
Many people look towards Rahul Gandhi, Congress, the Cockroach Janatha Party (CJP) and popular figures such as Neha Bora because they want an alternative to the BJP. They may see these political forces as a way to express their anger, defend democratic rights and demand change. We should not dismiss these people or simply attack the leaders they support. Their anger against unemployment, inequality, communalism and injustice is real. Instead, we must ask a more important question: Can these political forces challenge the system that produces these problems, or will they remain within its limits?
These parties and figures should not automatically be treated as identical. Their programmes, methods and political positions may differ. Each must be judged by its actual programme, its relationship with working people and its willingness to challenge capitalist power. The danger is that people may begin to believe that changing a leader or electing a different party is enough to transform society. Popularity, good intentions and parliamentary victories cannot replace the independent organisation of workers and youth. Even genuine anger can eventually be absorbed into the existing system if it is not connected to a movement that challenges the power of capital.
Marxists must engage with the people who support these political forces. We should participate in common struggles, discuss political differences openly and explain the limits of reformist politics through practical experience. The aim is not to isolate ourselves from people who support Congress, CJP or popular leaders, but to help build a movement that does not depend on them.
What Should Be the Political Foundation?
Calling for a workers’ movement is not enough. We must also be clear about what that movement should fight for.
Its foundation must be working-class independence, socialism and the liberation of all oppressed people. The struggle for workers’ rights must be connected to the struggle for Dalit liberation, women’s liberation and the defence of Muslims and other minorities against communal violence, discrimination and repression. Caste oppression, patriarchy and communalism cannot be treated as secondary issues that will disappear automatically after a socialist revolution. They must be fought as essential parts of the struggle for a new society.
The movement must organise around unemployment, low wages, insecure work, rising living costs, privatisation, caste discrimination, gender violence and attacks on democratic rights. These immediate struggles must be connected to a wider challenge to capitalist exploitation. We must oppose the BJP’s communal and authoritarian politics without making Congress or any other parliamentary force the final destination of the opposition. We must defend democratic rights without confusing liberal democracy with socialism. We must also challenge Stalinist parties when they subordinate working-class independence to alliances with bourgeois and liberal forces.
The working class needs its own organisations, political programme and leadership. Workers and youth must become active participants in shaping their future, rather than remaining supporters of leaders who claim to speak on their behalf.
Breaking the Cycle
The bourgeoisie can move from one political form to another to preserve its power. When one method becomes ineffective, it can offer reforms, support liberal democracy or turn towards more authoritarian forms of rule. The form changes according to the political situation, but the underlying system of capitalist exploitation can survive.
Defeating the BJP in Parliament may be an important step in defending democratic rights, but it cannot be the final goal. Replacing the BJP with Congress, CJP or another political force will not, by itself, transfer economic and political power to the working class Young people should not place all their hopes in one leader, one party or one election. They should organise with workers, students and oppressed communities, build collective struggles and develop an independent political programme.
The real alternative is not simply another government or another popular leader. It is an independent movement of workers and youth, fighting alongside all oppressed people, to challenge capitalist power, break the cycle of bourgeois rule and establish a society based on working-class power.